Okay, here we go.

Amarillo by Morning: Nothing ever wrong with "King George," lots of stuff goes straight to the heart. This is a classic. 95

Much too Young: Garth Brooks is neither a love nor a hate with me, more like a "well, so what?" He knows the basic roots of country but doesn't really expand on them. 80

I Can Still Make Cheyenne: Didn't make me cry, but it's good. 90

For contrast about tears, here are two that get to me (neither about rodeos though):

The other King George: https://youtu.be/9-hBAwaH6CI

I've probably posted this track by Linda Hargrove on your Texas-based threads several times before, but it always gets me teary (perfectly written and sung): https://youtu.be/qvGa8zbbGOM